Fiber cement siding vs vinyl siding because of its price point and ease of installation, vinyl siding has captured a significant portion of the siding industry. Fiber cement siding is unique material made from a blend of cellulose fiber mixed with sand, silica, and portland cement. This means that vinyl siding is about 2 12 times thinner than hardieplank. Fiber cement siding offers numerous benefits as a replacement for vinyl siding. Vinyl siding is more affected by fire and extreme heat than hardieplank. It is also quickly becoming a popular option for housing exteriors.
Over time, age and mother nature will deteriorate any siding product on your home. These areas include, but not limited to, penetrations, flashings, plank and trim connections, and in some cases, between plank joints. Small cracks can be repaired with a special patching compound before they cause breaks, saving you the work of removing and replacing a damaged panel. Dunnedwards vinyl patching compound this premixed vinyl patching compound is a general purpose, waterbased spackling compound for patching holes and nailheads. Its specially formulated for easy application and sanding, dries fast and holds tight.
When building or remodeling a home, one of the many important decisions to be made is which exterior siding to use. This would probably be the least expensive method but would require some efficiency using a cement trowel. Best quality v patching dents, chips and cracks can be filled using a good quality cement patching compound. The calculation varies based on the type of siding. How to repair concrete with a vinyl concrete patch. This article describes repair procedures for cosmetic or functional siding issues that may arise such as loose siding, winddamaged siding, siding paint or coating failures, and siding gaps, especially gaps at fiber cement siding butt joints where lap siding is installed. Spackle understand these similar but not interchangeable wall patching putties so you can pick the right one for your wall repair projectand get tips for pulling it off like. Avoid using resin, rosin or cementcoated fasteners that can discolor vinyl flooring. However, i have not found a product specifically made for patching fiber cement siding. All you need is a small trowel to make nonstructural repairs to concrete surfaces. Both james hardie siding and vinyl siding are viable options. Mar 22, 2014 you can contact the office of united home experts at 5088818555. In other words, you can purchase a patching compound that contains additives these are usually labeled as containing vinyl or acrylic,etc. Vinyl siding can be backed with foam sheathing or insulation, providing greater exterior.
James hardie siding has gained a loyal base of contractors and. Here, we will be comparing vinyl siding to james hardie fiber cement siding. Introduced in the 1960s, vinyl was created as an alternative to aluminum siding. When comparing hardieplank to vinyl siding, which is best. Fiber cement siding fibre cement cladding in the uk and fibro in australia is a building material used to cover the exterior of a building in both commercial and domestic applications. A cable line was run through the siding when the previous home owners lived there but the cable line is no longer there.
Planipatch is an ultra fastdrying, selfcuring, polymermodified, cementbased patching compound that rapidly develops high compressive strength. If either material is in need of repair, where planks panels need replacing. How do your prices compare to the prices of brick and vinyl. Repairs and fills spalls surface imperfections and cracks up to. Step 1 clean debris away from crack before you apply any type of vinyl concrete patch to the crack in the wall or the floor, you should make sure that the area is clear of any debris. Whether your dream house is a classic colonial, ladylike victorian or handsome craftsman, our diverse and detailed siding options will help you create a historically accurate, architecturally correct and flatout gorgeous home. Two popular materials for siding are fiber cement, also called hardieplank, and vinyl.
Also, some fiber cement manufacturers have had issues caused by the various types of concrete manufactured throughout the globe along with the compound materials used in the blending process. Fiber cement siding is a manmade product made from a composite of sand. There are so many ways to screw this up these days it is unbelievable. The material is available in tubs or a 40pound bag. With wood, vinyl, stone, brick, or stucco, you might get only two or three of these. Get the answers to frequently asked questions about james hardie products. To learn more about this material, explore the pros and cons of vinyl siding. Compare costs, easy of installation, colors, painting options, durability, thickness, r value, length of life and more to decide which is the best siding for your home.
No matter how durable fibercement siding is, though, cracks can still occur. Contractors sometimes complain because the fibercement board kicks up clouds of cement dust. Fiber cement is a composite material made of cement reinforced with cellulose fibers. Refer to manufacturers recommendations for products that are compatible with fiber cement. Fly ash, which is sometimes substituted with silica sand, is a filler. Fastsetting, polymermodified, cementbased patching compound patching compound description planipatch is an ultrafastdrying, selfcuring, vinyl or urethane wear layers 5. For homeowners contemplating replacement of their home siding or a new home construction, material choice is a critical decision that can impact how one feels about their house for years to come. While it certainly has plenty of merits in comparison to aluminum, vinyl siding also has a number of limitations. Jan 11, 2014 another methods would be to skimcoat the surface using a portland cement based patching compound. When planipatch is mixed with planipatch plus, the planipatch plus system can be used as an embossing leveler or as a patch to fill voids over properly prepared vinyl. Unfortunately fiber cement siding products have taken on the term hardiplank just as tissue has turned into kleenex. Its possible to install fiber cement as a diy project, although because it weighs 2.
The modified thinset used with our product is a fortified cementbased mortar and should specifically conform to ansi american. Fastsetting, polymermodified, cementbased patching compound description planipatch is an ultra fastdrying, selfcuring, polymermodified, cementbased patching compound that rapidly develops high compressive strength. Vinyl siding in the contest between fibercement board siding, such as hardieplank and vinyl siding, almost all factors point to the side of fibercement board except for one thing the cost. Acrylic mortar compound can be found at most home improvement retailers and hardware stores under various brand and trade names. Concrete patching compound comes in a variety of formulas but typically consists of cement mixed with vinyl or other polymer resins for workability and bonding strength. We at newpro have a alternate view from our industry colleague, mr. You can choose from either straight or staggered shingles to complement your homes unique style. Its important to consider the appearance and aesthetics, the maintenance, the impact for home resale and the cost for both types of siding. Standard vinyl siding is based on material thickness, ranging from. Concrete repair products you should know about hunker. Fiber cement siding repair or patching reapplying caulking when it has begun to show signs of wear can help keep moisture from getting into the wall cavity. It has been marketed as an affordable, maintenancefree alternative to wood. For a more comprehensive look at the costs and details of repair, explore our siding repair cost guide.
Fibercement siding is lowcost for its rated lifespan and is easy to maintain when compared with other siding choices. Jan 16, 2020 installation of vinyl will be cheaper than its allnatural competitor and will have no painting and other maintenance costs down the line. A fastsetting, onecomponent, polymermodified, calcium aluminate, cement based, horizontal concrete patching compound. But it may take several years for your pocketbook to notice.
Dap platinum patch advanced exterior filler is formulated with innovative weather max. Our page top photo shows loose and improperly installed fiber cement siding on. We investigate fibercement sidings cost, installation, how long it lasts and what. Concrete patching compound can be used to repair damaged concrete surfaces including cracks and holes. Learn about hardie board fibercement siding and that budget standby, vinyl. This creates a dense, durable material that can be formed into shingles, planks, or panels for installation on homes and buildings. Hardieplank siding, installing fiber cement planks on. In general, patching compounds are designed for shallow pits and holes up to 14 inch deep and covering relatively small areas. A vinyl concrete patch is a selfadhering, quickdrying patch that anyone can use to repair their cracked concrete wall or floor. Trying to superthin a patching product by adding additional water to make it pourable will only weaken the product and turn it to dust underfoot.
In terms of outward appearance, though, thickness does not matter, except in the case of texture. While it is sometimes necessary to remove an entire fiber cement plank from a wall, for the purposes of this article we will assume that the homeowner wants to patch a relatively small area and not remove and replace. Homeadvisors siding comparison guide explores the differences, pros, and cons of fiber cement and vinyl, including information on james hardies hardie board hardiplank fiber cement. To start, vinyl can become more brittle with age and exposure to the. Nov 14, 2010 to patch the crack shown in this article, we used quikrete vinyl concrete patcher, a selfbonding cement mix made specifically for repairing broken, chipped or loose concrete and masonry, as well as filling medium to large cracks. Always check the labeling to make sure the materials are compatible. In this video i show how i installed fiber cement siding to finish the exterior walls of the new room. Pulverized sand, cement, and wood pulp are mixed with water to make a slurry, which is rolled out and pressed together into sheets. Dents, chips, cracks and other minor surface damage in james hardie siding and trim products can be filled with cementitious patching compound.
Hardie board is a fibercement board made from sand, cement, and wood fibers that was introduced in the 1980s as an alternative to vinyl siding. Made of a special blend of exterior grade vinyl resin, fine sand, and portland cement. The james hardie company, makers of hardieplank, recommends the use of a cement patch product made of an acrylic mortar compound for patching their siding products. Fiber cement provias choice vinyl siding vs fiber cement. Fastsetting, polymer modified, cementbased patching compound. Hardieplankis composed of cementlike materials and about 10percent to 5percent cellulose wood fibers. In this guide, we compare the benefits and costs between fiber cement panels, also called hardiplank vs vinyl siding. How much does it cost to replace vinyl with fiber cement. Since the greatest concern you voiced was the lack of insulation in your extension, we recommend vinyl composite siding, also know as insulated vinyl siding. This product offers the convenience of being able to be used immediately, without mixing. So many real estate agents, contractors, and others refer to any fiber cement siding as hardiplank siding. Fiber cement siding looks like wood, but its actually a tough, industrialmaterial alternative thats waterproof, fireproof insectresistant, making it a very popular choice for most homeowners. Protecting your homes exterior needs a sturdy material that resists common outdoor threats like pests, extreme temperatures and harsh weather. Fibercement siding can have a classic or contemporary look in a durable siding thats.
When planipatch is mixed with planipatch plus, the planipatch plus system can be. Available in a variety of shapes and sizes, you can choose a primed, factorypainted or stainedfinish and decorative. Shingle fiber cement siding come in individual shakes and 4, 8, or 12 foot strips with either woodgrain or handsplit textures. Now the cheap, temporary solution to fixing the siding. Patching compounds do not contain the same additives that are contained in real self leveling compounds. A primer would be required prior to the application of the skimcoat product. You can contact the office of united home experts at 5088818555. Whats the difference between selfleveling cement and. Comparing vinyl and fiber cement secondary factors.
Fastsetting, polymermodified, cementbased patching compound. Our marketing hat is off to james hardie for creating such a brand. Dec 01, 2017 a demonstration on how to install hardieplank siding. How to fix damaged fiber cement siding united home experts. Were happy to make revisions based on your knowledge of vinyl siding for. Not only our bestselling product, its north americas most popular brand of siding. However, even this stuff isnt impervious to the test of time and the forces of nature, so you might find yourself needing to give your siding. Fiber cement costs more than vinyl but less than wood, brick or stone. Frequently asked questions resource center james hardie.
1467 401 1613 656 1617 1348 704 926 550 689 1013 10 1597 1423 1148 649 1200 12 1087 1338 112 742 119 1249 1366 372 460 1072 23 633 1445 377 967 776 391 944 737 640 110 257 860